Mysteriously Yours Dinner Theatre: Getting Hitched | Toronto Teacher Mom

Mysteriously Yours Dinner Theatre: Getting Hitched

Sunday, February 15, 2015

Last month, I received an invitation from Alfred Hitchmock to attend an engagement party in honour of his daughter Kelly-Grace. The famous director of The Angry Birds was in attendance, along with his star actress turned assistant, yet what began as an evening of celebration soon turned into a night of... murder! Dun, dun, dun! Fortunately, this was all part of the latest Mysteriously Yours Dinner Theatre show produced by Lili and Brian Caws and no directors were harmed in the making of Getting Hitched

Mysteriously Yours Dinner Theatre: Getting Hitched - Chef's Soup

The menu for the evening was compiled by Executive Chef Justine Voutt. My friend selected the Chef's Soup Creation, pictured above. I ordered an arugula salad with tomato, radicchio and feta cheese in a lovely fresh basil and red wine vinaigrette.

Mysteriously Yours Dinner Theatre: Getting Hitched -arugula salad

For the main course, my friend chose the Maple Dijon Chicken served with caramelized rice pilaf and green beans. When her dish was served, I almost regretted not ordering the same one, since I love chicken. But I always ordered chicken and wanted to try something different.

Mysteriously Yours Dinner Theatre: Getting Hitched - maple dijon chicken

I ended trying the Provençale Beef Stew, even though I'm not a big fan of stew in general. What sealed the deal for me was that the tender beef and vegetables stewed in red wine and French herbs were served over garlic mashed potatoes. Yum! It was incredibly delicious but very filling. Mind you, I may have indulged in one or two dinner rolls as well.

Mysteriously Yours Dinner Theatre: Getting Hitched - Provençale beef stew

Once we finished our main course, the fun began. The actors made their rounds throughout, interacting with guests and dropping clues here and there. This is always so much fun and I really admire how they can improvise so well. Then the real show began and we soon bore witness to a back-stabbing murder in a world where Bates Motel meets Mad Men. The cast included Brigitte Solem (Breakout Kings, Little Mosque on the Prairie), Allan Cooke (Murdoch Mysteries, Reign), Debbie Collins (A Chorus Line), Tom Melissis (Da Vinci's Inquest, Due South), Stephanie Folkins, and Paddy Forde. 

Mysteriously Yours Dinner Theatre: Getting Hitched - Brigitte Solem
Tipsy a.k.a Brigitte Solem
Mysteriously Yours Dinner Theatre: Getting Hitched - Allan Cooke
Archie a.k.a. Allan Cooke
Mysteriously Yours Dinner Theatre: Getting Hitched - Debbie Collins
Norma Bates a.k.a. Debbie Collins
Mysteriously Yours Dinner Theatre: Getting Hitched - Stephanie Folkins
Kelly-Grace a.k.a. Stephanie Folkins

On the whole, the show was good, not great, but entertaining enough. Of all the shows I've been to, Apprentice to Murder is still my favourite. But I have to say, they really exceeded my expectations with the party favours. Each guest received a sample of scrumptious white or milk chocolate bark, so much fancier than the roll of toilet paper we received at Once Upon a Murder. We ended up eating some after we polished off dessert. We had ordered Tiramisu, which was heavenly, and their Salted Chocolate Pot de Crème, a salted chocolate custard topped with caramel popcorn that was a little too sweet even for my taste.

Dinner and a show at Mysteriously Yours Dinner Theatre costs $81-$87 per person and includes a three-course meal, coffee or tea, taxes and gratuity. Soft drink, alcohol and coat check are extra. Dinner starts at 6:30 pm but the show doesn't start until 8 pm so you could arrive at 7 pm and still have time to order dinner. The dinner theatre is located on 2026 Yonge Street in Toronto and there is metered street parking available as well as a parking lot beside 1941 Yonge St. (formerly the Liquor Store) with $6 flat-rate parking.

Additional Reviews:

Apprentice to Murder (You're Fired!) - Spring 2012
The Fine Art of Murder - Fall 2012
Once Upon a Murder - Winter 2013
Uptwon Abbey - Summer 2013
Speakeasy - Spring 2014

You Might Also Like


  1. It looks like it was a great night!

    1. It was a fun way to spend some time with my bestie!

  2. I went to one many years ago they are fun.

  3. I would love to try something like this. You could say this is on my bucket list
    (Debbie W)

  4. I would love to do this. It seems like a lot of fun.

  5. I would love to go check this out!

  6. Oh my goodness that looks like a wonderful night! How fun!

  7. What a great way to spend an evening! Lots of fun, and the food looks great too!

  8. I've been wanting to do a dinner theater show for a long time now. Just have to find a friend to do it with

  9. What fun great way to spend an evening when its cold out

  10. Oh wow! the food looks amazing! Glad you had a fun time!

  11. I've often wondered about these murder mysteries. They intrigue me because I didn't know how they worked or how the "audience" got involved. I wanted to know what they were about. I think this would be a blast to do with some girlfriends. I really need to set one of these up in my area. I think my friends and I would have a great time. I like that it is done with a meal. Thats a nice bonus. When I eat out, I tend to always go for the same things. Good for you for trying something new. It looks delicious. Thanks for the interesting post.

  12. I love Mysteriously Yours and have been there many times! I should return for this show!


Thanks for taking the time to leave a comment here on Toronto Teacher Mom. Hope you have a great day!

Follow on Facebook

Follow on YouTube

Follow on Pinterest